cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)
In Ann Leckie's Translation State, we are finally getting to see a bit of the culture of the Presger Translators - descendants of humans who were essentially kidnapped and genetically altered to be able to interface with both the very, very alien Presger and the humans they originated from.

Spoilers ho... )

It's really fucked up, regardless of species. I'm about halfway through the book and I don't know if a societal change for the Translators is in the cards here? but as a human here on earth I can say, even in full awareness that I'm preaching to the choir: children have a fucking right to age-appropriate comprehensive sex ed, virginity fetishization is for the birds, and anyone who would valorize "submissive" wives over equal partners in marriage needs to sit down and take a good long hard look at their life and their choices.
cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)
I've talked about how the Republicans aren't good faith partners in democracy... but that's not the problem, the problem is that the political classes among Deep Southern whites were never good faith partners in democracy, and even the Tidewater gentry wanted to limit it to their idealized-to-the-point-of-myth "yeoman farmer".

We can't shame Mississippi into improving their health and education systems (or their representatives into improving the nation's) by pointing out "you're dead last" because the political class among Deep Southern whites is somewhere between "doesn't care" (those who deserve education and medical care will still get it) and "actively hostile" (why are we wasting tax money on education and medical care for the rabble???)

I've also talked about how the "heritage" of the Appalachians has nothing to do with the Confederate battle flag, that the forebears of the Appalachian people who wave that flag fought for the Union - but it does accurately represent their "heritage" of screaming "you're not the boss of me!!!" at anyone who seems to be telling them what to do. Fly that flag, boys, I won't argue with you anymore. (My heritage is still "shooting at people flying that flag" though...)

And then (and ask me how many times I heard this from my half-Appalachian mom) there's the resentment politics of "they are getting something for free that I had to work my ass off for." ("If we had a bigger budget for freebies, you could have gotten it for free too..." "No, I'm proud of how hard I work! Everything I have, I got on my own...") (and I guess that's still better than 'The Company gave me everything I have and I'm grateful for it')

and meanwhile my Yankee ass is up here like "what do you mean deserve education and medical care???" "what do you mean, 'on my own'? you went to public schools, you drive on public roads, the government insures your bank deposits and makes sure the people who sell your food aren't poisoning you...")

We used to find common ground to agree on even if we had to straight up make some up. The Supreme Court used to occasionally make us put on a get-along shirt. (Mileage varied as to whether the Yankees or the Deep South got to decide which way we were collectively going...) But there doesn't seem to be the willingness to do that anymore, and the Supreme Court is definitely letting the Deep South steer right now...

How can we have a functional society when a third of the people don't even agree that we live in one?
cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)
am reading Colin Woodard's "American Nations" and while I have not completed the book yet these are my thoughts so far:
- the politics of the American Revolution were a lot more complicated than either my high school history classes or the movie 1776 let on
- also the Civil War
- like nobody ever talked about how outside the Tidewater gentry and their fascination with yeoman farmers the Southern elites were somewhere between 'suspicious of' and 'actively opposed to' democracy and said this out loud?
- also nobody ever talked about what led up to the Whiskey Rebellion (and how it was Alexander Hamilton's fault), only that George Washington gloriously put it down, but Woodard at least gives the impression it was justified?
- I knew racism almost prevented the annexation of Hawai'i but I did not know that racism actually did prevent the annexation of most of Mexico in the 1840s (paraphrase: 'yes, we will take Texas and some of the border territories where there are already a lot of Americans living but... while we have validly conquered the rest of Mexico we do not want to be in charge of all these icky brown people, go about your business.')
- Appalachian folks: 'we hate all of you but we will team up with the enemies of the ones we hate most to fight them' - yeah that tracks (and for all that Appalachian people now loudly wave the Confederate battle flag and scream 'this is our heritage!!!!', in the Civil War the ones they hated most were the Deep South planter elites, ever so slightly more than they hated the Yankee busybodies, so they joined the Union army, even forming an Alabama unit)
- also in fairness given that most others held a view of Appalachia that boiled down to 'my god you are barbarians, have you considered civilizing yourselves according to my preferred model' I kind of see where that comes from?

- it is a miracle the United States has held together for 200+ years and in my cynical moments I wonder if it might not have been better if it hadn't
cathyw: Gromit in a blue chair reading "Men are from Mars, Dogs are from Pluto" (books)
I started listening to the audiobook of Alexandra Rowland's "A Taste of Gold and Iron" and just couldn't get into it; I was wondering why everyone was raving about it? I think the narrator was just not good (for example, she pronounced "Kadou", the main character's name, four different ways(*) in the first chapter).

Have started reading it with my eyes instead of my ears and it's going much better.

(*) If the four different pronunciations had been in dialogue I might have bought it? based on a comment he made, his name is transliterated into not!Turkish from not!French and he explicitly mentions that the not!French origin word ("cadeau") is pronounced differently. But I think all the uses of his name in that first chapter were either in the narration proper or by speakers of not!Turkish, so it should have been consistent. Pretty sure based on what he said that the not!Turkish pronunciation is KAH-doh?)

Profile

cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)
Cathy

January 2025

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12 131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 1st, 2025 07:15 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios